Specific hypothesis designed to answer a clinically relevant question | Exploratory correlative surveys |
Appropriate control populations | No control population |
Incorporation of factors that influence microbiome data (ie, host genes, age, sex, diet, drugs) | No acknowledgement of potential confounders |
Longitudinal study design | Cross-sectional study design |
Large cohort | Small cohort |
Consistent storage and processing of samples | Ad hoc storage and processing of samples |
Accounting for potential contamination of low biomass samples | Processing low biomass samples in the same manner as high biomass samples |
Correction for multiple hypothesis testing | No correction for multiple hypothesis testing |
Publishing raw data and detailed methods (including code) for obtaining results | Not making raw data and detailed methods publicly available |
Interdisciplinary team | Lack of expertise |
Multiomic approach | Approach focused on 16S rRNA data |
Discovery and validation cohorts | Only discovery cohort |
Preserving samples | Discarding samples once study is complete |